Grief and Joy

Sorrow and Pronoia

Harbinger: Joy and Grief

— an excerpt from my new book, Enlightenment for Rebels: Celebrating Our Wild and Sacred Earthly Selves in Jubilant Defiance of Disembodied Spirituality

In 2005, I published the first edition of Pronoia Is the Antidote for Paranoia: How the Whole World Is Conspiring to Shower You with Blessings.

Four years later came the expanded 400-page version, with 55% additional new material. Translated editions bloomed across the world: Spanish, Italian, Greek, and Turkish. I became the godfather prophet of pronoia.

The term itself was born in the 1970s from the mind of author John Perry Barlow, who envisioned it as paranoia’s radiant twin—“the suspicion that the universe is a conspiracy on your behalf.”

But Barlow didn’t develop the notion beyond his brief definitions. That project became my calling, and I pursued it with the fervor of an archaeologist uncovering a lost civilization. I resolved to be relentless in naming and celebrating all that is beautiful and interesting and healing in our bewildering world.

My philosophy rests on three radical propositions: that the universe is a prodigious miracle created for our amusement and illumination; that all of creation conspires to liberate us from suffering while motivating us and educating us to love with precision, intelligence, and courage; and that life delivers exactly what we need—not what we want, but what our souls require—to fulfill our deepest purposes. (PS: These worthy goals may take more than one incarnation to accomplish!)

Core tenets:

· Evil is boring, sterile, and stupid.

· Cynicism is intellectual laziness masquerading as sophistication.

· Fear is a bad habit we can at least partially unlearn.

· Despair is an impotent luxury with no redemptive power.

· Joy is fascinating, revelatory, and necessary.

· Love is an act of heroic genius, requiring bold perseverance and cultivated skill.

· Pleasure is not an indulgence but a birthright.

· Receptivity is a superpower.

But now the plot thickens: I am not a saccharine optimist who ignores life’s brutal realities. At the core of my perspective on pronoia lies an intimate, unflinching relationship with darkness. I don’t ignore or transcend shadows; I engage and negotiate with them.

Here’s a key element of my formulation: Yes, life orchestrates a vast conspiracy to keep us supplied with blessings, but what constitutes blessings? Ten million dollars? A gorgeous body? A hassle-free marriage with a perfect soulmate? A mansion filled with lavish accessories?

Maybe. But more often, the blessings arrive as plot twists we didn’t anticipate. They may bring dizzying adventures that remake us, gifts so unexpected we hardly know what to do with them, challenges that invite us to become smarter and wilder and kinder, and conundrums that dare us to grow luminous and numinous.

LIsten free to the song about that:

+

Among the conundrums that have dared me to grow more luminous and numinous is a tragicomic irony about my own soul’s assignment.

The realization slammed into me years ago. I was driving on Highway 1 north of Point Reyes, California after a rare argument with my beloved partner, determined to cool my troubled heart by staring at the white sky and grey ocean until they scoured me clean. A storm seemed imminent. The waves were bruised and restless.

Needing a break and wanting to write down a torrent of tormented thoughts in my notebook, I pulled over into a gravel turnout and parked. When I got out of the car, I had to concentrate on anchoring myself in the face of the steady gusts. Soon I noticed a shrine wedged down near the ground between two boulders. It was modest, but every object within it radiated stubborn endurance.

Wilted, mud-heavy lilies formed a roughly circular boundary around the ceremonial space. There were three candles in glass jars and three dead starfish. A child’s rubber boot, pink once, was now sun-blanched to a weary rose. A weather-beaten teddy bear with one eye missing, its remaining eye cloudy and scratched, gazed outward with a look of baffled tenderness.

There were messages, too: handwritten notes on thick index cards stuffed into rock crevices. Some were barely legible, half-erased by the elements:

We miss you.

Come visit us in dreams. Forgive us.

You changed us.

A few stones had been painted with spirals, hearts, and a stick-figure family holding hands beneath a wan sun. A single abalone seashell was positioned at the center like a small altar bowl, mottled with rainbow flashes whenever the clouds parted.

The whole shrine had the look of having been tended by many hands at various times, but also neglected for long stretches, as if grief came in unpredictable waves.

It was woebegone, unglamorous, and defiant in its shabbiness. I imagined it to be a shrine for a sorrow too enormous or complicated to fit into the easy categories of public mourning.

I stood before it too long. The wind moaned in strange harmonics around the rocks, like an animal circling me. The sky became a color I had never seen before, a blend of purple, silver, black and blue. A seagull’s cry cut through the wind and raised the hairs on the back of my neck. Instead of the usual squawk, I swear it shrieked my name three times: “Rob! Rob! Rob!”

Then a rupture rose up in me from solar plexus to throat: I felt an alien emotion that wasn’t mine blooming in my chest. It was a denser, older, more electric version of empathy.

The grief didn’t feel like it belonged to me, exactly, nor even to one family or one tragedy. It felt like a delta of losses converging from the whole wide world: every drowned wish, every vanished child, every unspoken apology, every hurt creature wailing in the great chain of being. I imagined it as a collective sorrow that had been temporarily stored in this heap of objects and that finally found me available and unguarded enough to hold it.

My knees buckled. I felt simultaneously enormous and hollow, as if I’d become a vessel whose only purpose was to contain this tsunami of loss. The sensation was both exquisitely precise and overwhelmingly diffuse. It was like being pierced by a thousand fine needles made of age-old sadness, each one carrying a story of irretrievable absence.

There was also a sweetness in the anguish, an alien honey-thick tenderness woven through the pain. I wasn’t drowning in it; I was being initiated by it. My chest expanded to accommodate a surge of anonymous agony I couldn’t name: the mother who never got to say goodbye, the lover who died mid-sentence, the child who vanished into an ocean, or the merciless machinery of human cruelty.

I wasn’t being punished or overwhelmed; I was being trusted. And that trust wrestled itself down into my bones like a hot coiling drill. I swore I felt it in my spine and pelvis and both femurs. It was as if I’d been chosen to receive this blessed curse because of my capacity to hold tremendous quantities of affliction that didn’t belong to me.

The sorrow carried intelligence. It had weight, temperature, and texture. It asked not for fixing or fleeing, but for presence without flinching. I felt like the grief was reorganizing me, enlarging my power to love without conditions or caveats.

As the rupture vibrated in my belly and chest, it unleashed a further breach. Mixed with the sorrow was a sense of an unmistakable assignment.

The grief didn’t merely want release. It wanted interpretation, reanimation, and alchemy. It bid me to carry it forward without corrupting it, so it would be neither sentimentalized nor weaponized. I swear I heard it speak to me: I chose you because you won’t collapse or perform martyrdom or pretend it’s not happening.

I whispered aloud, “Why me?”

The ocean answered with a rogue wave that slapped the cliffs with such force I lurched backward. In that sonic boom of saltwater and stone, I heard the unmistakable response:

Because you already praise holy beauty. Now learn to praise holy hurts.

+

As vividly as if it were now, I remember standing at that woebegone shrine while the vast grey Pacific Ocean shoved a massive, unwieldy truth into my bloodstream. That was the moment I fully coalesced into the living container who praises the miraculous with fervor while metabolizing the unbearable.

I fully grasped my twin assignments: to celebrate the world audaciously and carry its grief tenderly.

Ever since, I understand that my drive to gather the world’s grief springs from love: profound, unreasonable adoration for our broken, magnificent world. To earn the right to ameliorate suffering, I must first feel it as deeply as it goes. To speak authentically about bliss and pleasure, I must be intimately familiar with sorrow.

Ever since, each praise-song I write has had to carry salty tears. Every gift I offer the world is seasoned by my willingness to sit with what can’t be fixed but only felt and witnessed.

This is the harbinger’s burden and privilege: to be a bridge between what breaks us and what makes us whole. It means I’m not numbed by contradiction but buoyed by completion.

I extol the world’s beauty with ferocity precisely because I know how fragile it is. I celebrate wonder with such abandon because I can hold horror without flinching.

My initiation at the windswept shrine became foundational to everything I now understand about Rebel Enlightenment.

The disembodied spiritual traditions I reject promise transcendence from suffering. Avoid suffering at all costs, they say. They exalt an escape velocity that launches us beyond the messy, mortal realm into a sterile, pristine elsewhere.

But the liberating illuminations that have remade me again and again arrive through my willingness to be a full-bodied vessel for both ecstasy and anguish.

When I expanded to hold that collective grief without numbing or fleeing, I didn’t fly away into heavenly consolation. I dived more deeply into my life’s mission. And that descent made me exquisitely available.

Every Ecstatic Healing Derangement and Friendly Shock Awakening I’ve experienced since then has confirmed this: The sacred doesn’t seek the sanitized or the safely detached.

It hunts for those of us who are brave and brazen enough to be vulnerable, rumpled, and shockingly alive. Can we hold grief in one hand and rapture in the other without needing to choose between them?

This is the paradox at the heart of Sacramental Incandescent Embodiment: Only by refusing to abandon our earthly selves can we become spacious enough for the healing elixir of inscrutable divinity to move through us without destroying us.

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

Check out my Linktree, with links to other things I create: linktr.ee/robbrezsny

If you’d like to buy my book Enlightenment for Rebels: Celebrating Our Wild and Sacred Earthly Selves in Jubilant Defiance of Disembodied Spirituality:

It’s available at all online stores, and you can get a 25% discount here: https://tinyurl.com/SacredEarthySelves

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

FREE WILL ASTROLOGY

For the Week of September 17

VIRGO (Aug. 23-Sept. 22): If I were writing this horoscope for the Gun Lovers’ Gambling Porn website, I might counsel my Virgo readers to maintain strict control over their wickedness, debauchery, and decadence. Why? Because now is a time when vices and sins are even more likely than usual to sow chaos and spawn big messes. However, since you are reading my oracle in a more genteel publication and are almost certainly a refined person of high integrity, I’m confident there will be minimal uproar if I dare you to tap into your raw animal energy and unruly instinctual nature. I believe it’s time to at least experiment with wilder aspects of your deep self.

LIBRA (Sept. 23-Oct. 22): The Real You and the Semi-Real You have been embroiled in a showdown with the False You. This is as tough and heroic a struggle as you’ve had to deal with in quite some time, though it has often been subtle and partially cloaked. I am of course rooting for the Real You and the Semi-Real You to emerge victorious from the conflict, though I also hope you don’t feel the need to humiliate and crush the False You. That part of you has sometimes served a valuable purpose and doesn’t deserve to be trashed. And what will become of the Semi-Real You after this drama is finished? I suggest you give it a modest place in your repertoire. Like the False You, it sometimes proves to be useful.

SCORPIO (Oct. 23-Nov. 21): Hummingbirds can fly backward. They’re the only birds capable of sustained reverse flight. This requires extraordinary wing flexibility and energy expenditure, but it gives them access to nectar that forward-only fliers have more difficulty sampling. Let’s treat this as a useful metaphor for you in the coming weeks, Scorpio. It may be that your progress and success won’t always come from advancing. Some rich resources may require the equivalent of reverse flight. Consider returning to conversations you thought were finished, revisiting places you’d mentally filed away as “done,” and extracting value from sources you’ve already passed by.

SAGITTARIUS (Nov. 22-Dec. 21): In chemistry, catalysts are substances that accelerate reactions without being consumed in the process. A tiny amount of catalyst can dramatically transform how quickly elements combine. An example is the enzyme catalase in our cells, which breaks down hydrogen peroxide (a byproduct of our metabolism) into water and oxygen millions of times faster than it would decompose on its own. I believe you are now in a phase when your catalytic powers are at a peak, Sagittarius. Be careful where you point that potency of yours! Make sure you really want to change what you’re capable of changing.

CAPRICORN (Dec. 22-Jan. 19): Every species adapts to its surroundings. Even harmful microbes evolve over time in order to survive. Syphilis, for instance, was once ferociously swift and deadly, but that intensity limited how far it could spread. So a gentler strain gradually evolved that allowed its hosts to live longer and pass it on more widely. Let this serve as a metaphor for how you handle your dark moods, odd compulsions, and brief bouts of craziness. Befriend the mild, manageable versions of these states and give them space to be felt and understood. Over time, the harsher, more destructive versions will lose ground and fade from power.

AQUARIUS (Jan. 20-Feb. 18): Paleontologists know that some dinosaurs traveled in herds with a specific formation: the most vulnerable members gathered in the center, protected by stronger individuals on the perimeter. It was a savvy way to run things, ensuring the group would thrive. I hope you’re willing to borrow some dinosaur wisdom, Aquarius. The coming weeks will be a good time to apply it to your own life. Who or what needs protection? What vulnerable projects or relationships deserve to be surrounded and shielded? Are you willing and able to use your strength to guard what’s tender and growing? Be a shepherd, a steward, a defender.

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

If you would like to support my work, consider:

buying my Expanded Audio. Horoscopes and Daily Horoscopes

which includes a long-term look at the coming months as well as a new shorter-term report about the coming days

and/or

becoming a paid subscriber to my Free Will Astrology Newsletter

and/or

donating at my Paypal site: paypal.com/paypalme/GiftsForRob

(contribute as Friends and Family)

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •

PISCES (Feb. 19-March 20): In ancient times, Hawaii’s Coconut Island was renowned for its healing powers—but on one condition. Those who sought its medicinal help couldn’t just expect the local spirits to do all the work, but had to take part in awakening the magic. Legend tells us that a seeker could be cured by swimming three times around the island. This participatory approach to healing mirrors your current situation, Pisces. You are close to a source of renewal, but if you hope to unlock its full strength, you must coax it out with your ingenuity.

ARIES (March 21-April 19): Realities you’ve been oblivious to will soon pop into view. Hints and signals you’ve been unconsciously pushing away will start flocking toward you. A lingering emotional numbness will thaw, and surges of feelings will pour into your awareness. Warning! At first, it may feel like an overload: too much sopping wet data arriving too quickly for you to organize or interpret. If you’re willing to be patient and focus on slowly metabolizing the influx, though, the apparent chaos will ultimately weave itself into a luminous web of new understanding.

TAURUS (April 20-May 20): In Peru’s Andean mountains, Indigenous and smallholder farmers cultivate a rich diversity of potato varieties, continuing a farming tradition rooted in the crop’s domestication thousands of years ago. Each variety thrives in slightly different soil, altitude, and climate. By planting many types at once, the farmers ensure that at least some crops will flourish no matter what conditions arise. I suggest you apply this way of thinking to your own life in the coming weeks, Taurus. Diversify your efforts instead of depending on a single plan or expectation. Plan for multiple small initiatives that will evolve with unique growth patterns.

GEMINI (May 21-June 20): In biology, many organisms survive harsh or unpredictable conditions by entering dormancy. This is a reversible state of greatly reduced metabolism and development. Seeds, spores, and the dormant stages of some small animals can remain viable for years until cues such as water, temperature, light, or nutrients signal that conditions are favorable again. Then they can resume growth, development, or activity, often rapidly. I suspect you may experience a comparable upsurge in the coming weeks, Gemini. A project or aspiration that seemed inert may reawaken and reignite.

CANCER (June 21-July 22): Novelist Kurt Vonnegut advised us to try some task that scares us every day of our lives. That may be a viable experiment for a Scorpio like him, but is it a wise prescription for us Cancerians, who like to feel secure and protected? Normally, I would say no. I’d recommend that you and I dare ourselves to wrestle with one of our fears no more than once per month. But the coming weeks may warrant a departure from our typical rhythms. I suspect we can fortify our long-term safety and peace through more frequent encounters with unpredictable episodes that rouse our hidden reserves of courage.

LEO (July 23-Aug. 22): The ancient Greeks believed that the goddess Harmonia presided over the blending of opposites into balanced beauty. Her dad was the god of war and her mom the goddess of love, so she had a lot of practice. In her line of work, tension between different forces could produce elegant unity rather than conflict. In alignment with astrological omens, I’ve appointed Harmonia to be your guardian angel in the coming weeks, Leo. I urge you to call on her dynamically and frequently. Rifts and splits and divisions that have never before been possible to heal are now swayable by the collaborative efforts of you and the goddess.

• • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •